Volume 49, Issue 3
BPLA Judges Dinner Summary
Carissa Ryan
Nutter McClennen & Fish
By Carissa Ryan,Nutter
On May 31, 2018, the Boston Patent Law Association hosted its Annual Dinner to Honor the Federal Judiciary at the Moakley Courthouse. We could not have ordered up a better day, as we enjoyed a warm (but not too hot) sunny day on the lawn at the Courthouse before heading inside for a lovely evening. Over 250 guests attended, including 21 judges from the
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit
, the
U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts
, and the
Patent Trial and Appeal Board of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office
. The inclusion of the judges from the PTAB were a welcome addition, as six judges who live locally were able to attend and indicated how appreciative they were of the invitation.
The dinner was held in honor of the 21 judges in attendance, along with their colleagues who were unable to attend, to demonstrate the BPLA’s appreciation for the hard work these jurists put in to provide a fair justice system that treats intellectual property matters with respect and importance. During the dinner, the implementation of the new
Local Rule 16.6 for Patent Proceedings
was also highlighted, as it was the eve of the rule coming into effect. President Rory P. Pheiffer highlighted the collaborative efforts of members of the Federal judiciary—including Judges
, and
, among others—and of BPLA members—including
Erik Belt
Barbara Fiacco
Susan Glovsky
Monica Grewal
Michael McGurk
Andrew O’Connor
Lisa Tittemore
, and the recently appointed Judge
Dalilia Wendlandt
, among others—in formulating the new rule.
While the dinner honors the entire Federal judiciary, including the administrative judges at the USPTO, one highlight of the evening was the presentation of the 12th annual
BPLA Distinguished Public Service Award
U.S. District Court Judge F. Dennis Saylor, IV
. President Pheiffer presented this year’s Award to Judge Saylor in recognition of his many years of public service, first in the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Boston, and since 2004 as a Federal Judge. President Pheiffer noted that Judge Saylor’s upcoming succession of Chief Judge Patti Saris as the Chief Judge of the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts is a clear reflection of the respect and admiration he has earned from his colleagues over his 14 years on the bench. It was noted that his colleagues, and those that have tried cases in front of him, were all quick to compliment his judicial temperament, as well as the careful and thoughtful consideration he gives each matter. President Pheiffer further noted that, at least statistically, Judge Saylor appears to appreciate the value and importance of intellectual property—having found claims to be valid nearly 85 percent of the time, and having never found a patent to be unenforceable.
In accepting the award, Judge Saylor provided a history lesson involving
Henry Ford’s fight against George Selden
—sometimes dubbed as one of the original “patent trolls.” George Selden, a patent attorney, was issued
U.S. Patent No. 549,160
for a “road-engine,” from which he and a financer were able to collect royalties from a number of companies involved in the infancy of the automotive industry. Henry Ford, however, thought the patent was worthless and decided to fight the patent infringement suit brought against Ford Motor Company. Henry Ford lost at the district court level but was vindicated at the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit when the court agreed that the engines used in Ford’s automobiles were based on the Otto engine, not the Brayton engine which was the focus of the Selden patent. Judge Saylor’s takeaway from this case? Keep it simple, as Henry Ford lost at the district court when his attorneys presented an evidence-heavy, highly technical case against succinct, easy to digest briefs from Selden, while on appeal Henry Ford’s new patent attorney focused on a few key issues to discredit Selden’s case.1
The night concluded with a keynote speech from
Dr. Latanya Sweeney
, a professor of Government and Technology in residence at Harvard University. Her keynote focused on the unforeseen consequences of technology, which can leave our democratic values up for grabs. Dr. Sweeney began by highlighting the many ways in which technology affects our lives and how seemingly arbitrary decisions in creating technology can force us to live by new rules. Further, rapid proliferation and replication of successful technologies can enact these changes seemingly overnight. After showing how plentiful vulnerabilities and unforeseen consequences can be in this environment, Dr. Sweeney spent the latter part of her keynote illustrating how everyone—from lawyers to technologists to students—can identify democratic vulnerabilities or unforeseen consequences and affect change for the better. Whether by pressuring individual companies to fix their platforms, or encouraging regulators to enact broader reform, careful thought and resulting action can safeguard long-held values and make our society a better place.
The BPLA thanks all of its members, and the members of the judiciary, who attended. The BPLA also thanks the sponsors for the event: Nutter; Goodwin Procter; Choate, Hall & Stewart; Hamilton, Brook, Smith & Reynolds; Lando & Anastasi; K&L Gates; McCarter & English; Mintz, Levin, Cohn, Ferris, Glovsky and Popeo; Morgan, Lewis & Bockius; Pepper Hamilton; Wolf, Greenfield & Sacks; Greenberg Traurig; Hoffman Alvary; Latham & Watkins; Proskauer Rose. The night would not be possible without the support of the members, the judiciary, or the sponsors.
________________ 1 Henry Ford also had a takeaway. In 1925, reflecting back on the case, he said, “No man has a right to profit by a patent only. That produces parasites, men who are willing to lay back on their oars and do nothing. If any reward is due the man whose brain has produced something new and good, he should get enough profits from the manufacture and sale of that thing.”
To see all photos from the event, please click
Christina Allegrini (Fresenius Medical Care), Heather Repicky (Nutter), The Honorable Judge Allison Burroughs (United States District Court – District of Massachusetts), Reza Mollaaghababa (Pepper Hamilton), Jay Cahill (Pepper Hamilton), The Honorable Judge Indira Talwani (United States District Court – District of Massachusetts), Tom Engellenner (Pepper Hamilton and BPLA Past President), and Tod Cochran (Pyle Rome) gather on the lawn for refreshments before the event.
Addie Fiske (U.S. Department of Justice), The Honorable Chief Judge Patti Saris (United States District Court – District of Massachusetts and the 2008 BPLA Distinguished Public Service Award Recipient), The Honorable Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV (United States District Court – District of Massachusetts and the 2018 BPLA Distinguished Service Award Recipient), The Honorable Judge Edward Harrington (United States District Court – District of Massachusetts), Jodi Gorton (Museum of Fine Arts), The Honorable Judge Nathaniel Gorton (United States District Court – District of Massachusetts), Sara Fiotto, and Anthony Fiotto (Goodwin Procter) smile for the camera on a picture-perfect evening.
Niharika Singh (Latham & Watkins) and Debbie Hinck (Latham & Watkins) socialize outside the courthouse.
Mark Solomon (Hamilton Brook and BPLA Past President), Dolores Reyna, The Honorable Judge Jimmie Reyna (US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit), and Deirdre Sanders (Hamilton Brook and BPLA President-Elect) enjoying cocktail hour on the lawn outside the John Joseph Moakley United States Courthouse.
Derek Roller (Nutter and BPLA Activities Chair), Liza Hadley (Nutter), Lisa Adams (Mintz Levin and BPLA Past President),and Ron Cahill (Nutter) pose for a picture.
BPLA President Rory P. Pheiffer presents U.S. District Court Judge Saylor with the BPLA Distinguished Public Service Award.
Addie Fiske (U.S. Department of Justice), The Honorable Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV (United States District Court – District of Massachusetts) (2018 BPLA Distinguished Service Award Recipient), and Dr. Latanya Sweeney (Harvard University and Keynote Speaker) enjoying their post-dinner conversation.
Keynote speaker Dr. Latanya Sweeney delivers her remarks.
< Previous Article
Table of Contents
2018 Ⓒ Boston Patent Law Association
Next Article >
Table of Contents
Message from the President Rory P. Pheiffer
Read more >
< Back
Officers and Board of Governors
Read more >
2nd Annual Summit on Life Sciences IP Due Diligence
Read more >
Community Calendar
Read more >
10 Millionth Patent
Read more >
Supreme Court Allows Recovery of Profits Outside of US
Read more >
New District Of Massachusetts Local Rules
Read more >
BPLA Family Day at the Aquarium
Read more >
Message from the Editor-in-Chief
Read more >
Job listings
Read more >
BPLA Comments on Notice of Proposed Rulemaking for Changes to Patent Trial and Appeal Board Trial Claim Construction Standard
Read more >
Members on the Move
Read more >
Judges Dinner Summary
Read more >
Comments on Changes in Examination Procedure Pertaining to Subject Matter Eligibility
Read more >
9th Annual
Invented here!
Read more >